Leadership Team

Jan Peneston: Executive Director

Jan Peneston is the Executive Director Camp Talooli.  Formerly, Jan Peneston was the full-time Camp Director at Camp Talooli for over 20 years.  In 2019, Jan was recognized by the American Camp Association (ACA) as the National Honor Award Recipient for her many years of service to Camp Talooli, camping in Upstate NY, as well as to the national organization of ACA. This will be Jan's 36th year working at Camp Talooli!

Kelly Peneston: Camp Director

Kelly Peneston is the Camp Director at Camp Talooli.  Formerly, Kelly was the Asssistant Camp Director, Boating Director and grew up at Camp Talooli as both a camper and a overnight counselor.  She is also on the Local Council of Leaders of the Upstate NY section of the American Camp Association. Kelly is a graduate of Hobart and William Smith Colleges and has a Master's Degree in Education from UMass Amherst. Kelly is trained as a School Psychologist.

Pam Southworth: Administrative Assistant/Bookeeper

Pam grew up at Camp Talooli as a camper, CIT, and Camp Fire club member. She previously worked as both a camp counselor and Waterfront Director, and was also a member of our volunteer Board of Directors. For the past several years, Pam has worked in our camp office. Her three children also work at/attend Camp Talooli throughout the summer.

Jeff Peneston:  Director of Educational Programs

Jeff Peneston is the Program Director at Camp Talooli and has held this position and many others at Camp Talooli for over 30 years.  Jeff has been an invaluable resource at Camp Talooli and is well known by campers and staff for his vast knowledge and ability to hold large crowds captive. In 2011 Jeff was named the New York State Teacher of the Year and in 2009 he spent a few months on board the Swedish Icebreaker Oden, helping to do research during the ship's voyage through Antarctica. Jeff recently retired from teaching Earth Science for the Liverpool School District and has started working for Camp Talooli in the "off-season" to develop year-round programming. 

Crystal Peneston: Assistant Camp Director - Program Specialist

In her role as an Assistant Camp Director, Crystal supervises our program and counseling staff and provides administrative assistance in the office. As a certified WSI, she also assists with lifeguarding and swim lessons. Previously, Crystal worked as a the Nature Director, as well as a Day and Resident Camp Counselor. She was also a camper and CIT at Talooli for many summers.  Crystal graduated from SUNY Brockport with degrees in Inclusive Childhood Education, Psychology and Creative Writing. She also has a Master's Degree in Curriculum from SUNY Oswego. Crystal currently works as a Special Education teacher.

Rachel Arnold: Assistant Camp Director - Youth Development Specialist

In her role as an Assistant Camp Director, Rachel oversees our Integration and Pre-K Day Camp Programs. She provdes individual support to counselors and campers, and she helps to mentor and evaluate our CIT 3s. Previously, Rachel worked as a day camp counselor and the Pre-K Program Director. She was also a camper and CIT at Talooli for many summers.  Rachel is a graduate of LeMoyne College and will be attending graduate school at The College of Saint Rose in the fall, studying School Psychology.

Matthew Peneston:  Program Director

Matthew Peneston is the Program Director at Camp Talooli.  In his role at Camp, Matthew helps to design and oversee our weekly themes and campwide activities. He also provides evening first aid support. Matthew has been on staff for more than 15 years and has also grown up at Camp Talooli in various positions such as Waterfront Director, lifeguard and day camp counselor.  Matthew is a certified EMT and teaching assistant.

Brian Lawler: CIT Director

Brian began attending Camp Talooli 15 years ago! After many years of attending camp as a camper, CIT, and counselor, Brian joined our CIT team in 2017. He is excited to return this summer to train the next generation of Talooli leaders. Brian is graduates this spring with a degree in Human Services from LeMoyne College

Mike Mesa: Head Counselor

Mike began attending Camp Talooli as a day camper when he was in elementary school and then proceeded to graduate from our counselor-in-training program. After working as both a day and overnight camp counselor for several summers, Mike stepped into the role of Head Counselor in 2020. Mike's job is to be a resouce and support to both our campers and counselors. In the fall, Mike will be a junior at Guilford College, studying Psychology.